All customer reviews

For years I have been struggling to find a mascara that doesn't leave black lid marks or flakes under my eye. I was recommended some 'tubing' mascara's including this one, which has given me back the confidence of not having to worry about panda eyes, and I forget I have it on. The best bit is it is removed with warm water! It's perfect for every day wear, however I would say it doesn't layer very well so if you are after a bolder lash, maybe for an evening look then try something like Sky high mascara by Maybelline. I have been able to recommend it to lots of friends and family who were also struggling, and they are all really happy too.

The original Staty Perfect Mascara is brill .. have been using it for years and I love it. Recently went to buy a new one and was pesuaded by the sales lady to ret their new Stay Perfect " Ultra" .. what a ,load of rubbish that is .. went in the bin . THIS one is fantastic ..does what is says on the tin.. washes off with warm water .. stays on all day ( and night if needs be ! ) and NEVER smudges. I also think it gives very good coverage to my blonde eyelashes .

The best tubing mascara I have found so far but it does dry out quite quickly. I have to replace it every three months or so. Doesn't smudge until it comes off in the shower.

Found this the best mascara I’ve ever used! Stays on in water swimming, no smudging and lengthen eye lashes great effect

I have eczema and really dry skin often very red and sore around the eyes. Because of the eczema creams and scratching or rubbing to deal with the irritation mascara always rubs off, smearing around the eyes and causing me to look like and panda and often making the bad skin worse. I have tried some very expensive mascaras from lancome and clinique and many waterproof variants but this is the ONLY MASCARA THAT STAYS PUT. You can do sport, swim, apply tons of moisturiser and no problem. Just wipe your eyes with warm water at the end of the day and it comes off. I'm never bothering get with another macara.

I’ve been using this mascara for over 6 years and I love it. In the past I’ve tried so many waterproof mascaras that have just left me with panda eyes but this mascara never smudges. I must admit that the first time I removed the mascara I did worry that they were my eyelashes coming off but realised it’s just the little tubes of mascara that cover each lash! Having moved to Australia 2 years ago I have struggled to find a mascara I like and have my mum send me Stay Perfect Mascara in the post!

Eyelashes clump together and very sticky. At 64 l haven't the thickest of lashes but thought l would end up with less trying to get mascara off,left with black bits over face.

I always come back to this. Stays on in the rain, the pool, if you rub your eyes and even if you cry. Removes easily with warm water, yet won't budge if you take off your eye makeup with a remover. It's the perfect answer to smudging and panda eyes.

I'm really surprised at the negative reviews because I LOVE this mascara! I honestly think this could be my HG (Holy Grail) mascara! Why? First of all this mascara claims to be smudge proof, flake proof etc & I absolutely agree with the claims as this mascara literally does not budge & will not come off until you remove it with warm water on a cotton pad/muslin cloth which is the only way it will come off, trust me I've tried everything else. When you remove the mascara it does look a bit like you've removed your lashes but trust me it's just the mascara that's removed! I didn't have any panda eyes either which is great! Not only do I love mascara as it literally does not budge but it also holds my curl which I was pleasantly surprised about as I usually need to use a waterproof mascara to hold my curl or my lashes will go straight but with this my lashes don't go straight. It gives my lashes a lot of length & volume (my lashes are naturally long btw) when I first put the mascara on I was really impressed as it made my lashes look soooo long, volumized & it really makes my eyes stand out. Also (Nearly forgot to mention) if you're the type of girl who just wants to remove her mascara along with the rest of her make-up with a wipe/cleanser or if you hate plastic bristles then I would not recommend this mascara to you. I just love this mascara (In case you haven't noticed lol!) it ticks all the boxes for me & I know the price isn't the cheapest but in my opinion it's worth it! I will definitely be buying this mascara again...and again! * Looking at the recent reviews this mascara is not going to be for everyone, it's a bit like Marmite you will either love or hate this mascara. I absolutely hate Marmite but I absolutely LOVE this mascara! I think I've rambled on enough lol! Hope this Helps! :)

I use a product under my eyes which I love the only downside is it makes my mascara smudge and I end up with darker eyes than I started with! I have been using a similar mascara with a higher price tag which is good but tends to flake. I thought I would try No7 stay perfect but didn't expect it to match up. I was wrong this product is great it doesn't smudge or flake and stays put all day. I would really recommend this product.