All customer reviews

Instead of buying a cheap eyeliner, I decided to spend a little more to get a better product, instead it leaves dark smudges around your eyes like a cheap eyeliner. Waste of money!

I was looking for a navy blue eye pencil and went for this one as I already have it in Deep Green. However I may as well have used black, as there was no difference! Maybe it is something to do with my skin tone. The Deep Green is a lovely colour; the problem is it tends to smudge, also I have to keep sharpening it. It is easier to apply than the Metallic Eyes pencil though, and I don't react to it (fingers crossed).

It does not drag your eyes or scratch , absolutely brilliant. Do not understand these people that say you cant sharpen it, of course you can. just need a two way pencil sharpener

I bought this about a week ago, in place of another brand which does stay perfect, only to be very disappointed. Half way through my day I was wondering why it looked like I was wearing blue eyeshadow in the crease of my eye and in my upper lid. Turns out it's the not so stay perfect eyeliner rubbing off. A waste of money for me and wouldn't recommend.

Every time i need to use this it needs sharpening, do not touch it!!! Complete waste of time and money

This eyeliner goes on really smooth and a good strong colour (I got black) - however, it smudges far too easily and I often realise it's half way under my eye!

The eyeliner goes on easily but doesn't stay in place, the first time I wore it on top and bottom lids I ended up with smudges under both eyes. I tried using it again just to line the top lids and within 2 hrs it had smudged. This is supposed to be waterproof but smudges withoutbeven coming into contact with water

I had this as a gift on one of boots over 60s days. Saw the comments about sharpening, I haven't had a problem I use a sharpener from a cosmetic counter and it works love it had the gold colour use it like an eye shadow under my eyeliner..

This is honestly the best eyeliner I have ever bought. It really does stay put and is very easy to apply as it glides on.

Amazing Eyes Pencil 05 Black - Is this the original pencil? Absolute waste of money. Product will not make a decent mark or draw any line on my eyelid (mature skin) or on my daughter's (youthful skin) over the eye shadow. Sharpening the pencil makes no difference. It does not deserve even one star.